Made In New York Pi…'s logo

Made In New York Pizza

Pizza

"Craving authentic New York pizza? We are your go-to destination for the best pizza in town. Our expertly crafted pies are made with the freshest natural ingredients & our dough made with famous NYC water, captures the true essence of New York style pizza. From classic cheese to gourmet toppings, each slice offers a taste of the Big Apple. Whether you're a local or just visiting, come savor the flavor at one of the top pizza places around. Experience the bustling ambiance and friendly service that make us a fan favorite. Join us and discover why our customers say we serve the best pizza in the Upper West Side!"

Rating
4.6
1,100 reviews
Facebook Likes
737
792 follows
Category
Pizza place
Monthly Visits
8,118
2025/4
Address
421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, United States
+1 646-484-6200
[email protected]
Website Facebook Instagram

Extra Info

Title: Top Rated NY Style Pizza | Hand-Tossed Slices, Pies & Squares


URL Source: https://www.madeinnewyorkpizza.com/


Markdown Content:
Made in New York Pizza – Authentic New York‑Style Slices in Manhattan



OUR NEW YORK CITY LOCATIONS


Image 1



Image 2



Image 3



Image 4



Image 5



Pizza may have started in Italy, but it was perfected in NYC. Made in New York Pizza is built on a foundation of fresh, natural ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and that legendary NYC water that gives our dough its signature taste. From Midtown to the West Village to the UWS, we’re serving up NY-style pizza so irresistible, you’ll find yourself coming back for more – and fast. This is New York pizza at its finest.


LEGENDARY SLICES, EVERY TIME


You’ve found the home of New York’s most irresistible slices. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, one bite is all it takes to taste the allegiance to true NY-style pizza. At Made in NY Pizza, the city’s signature flavor isn’t just served – it’s celebrated. Grab a slice and taste the legend!


Image 6


Image 7


Image 8


Image 9


Image 10


Image 11: @madeinnewyorkpizza


Made In New York Pizza

@madeinnewyorkpizza


⭐️8.3 @barstoolsports Famous Spicy Pepperoni Square 🌶️ U.W.S: 421 & 271 Amsterdam Ave, 2563 Broadway West Village: 561 Hudson St Midtown: 512 7th Ave




  • Image 12: CHEESE SLICE, FTW 🍕 Our belief is pretty simple: Pizza is art & every aspect of it matters: Dough, sauce & cheese. Creating it is a ritual we’ve been practicing since our first shop opened up. You’ll taste the difference. ✔️<br> 📍 New York City <br> 📌 Locations in West Village, Upper West Side, Midtown West & Broadway<br> #PIZZA #NYC #NYCPIZZA #MADEINNEWYORK #MANHATTAN




  • Image 13: 🍕 INTRODUCING THE NEW MARGHERITA. Stracciatella is king on this one, complimented by tomato, pecorino, basil & extra virgin olive oil. It’s just as crazy as it looks too. 😏 With FIVE locations across Manhattan, you don’t really have an excuse to not get this one in your hands. ♥️ <br> 📍 Upper West Side, West Village, Midtown West, Broadway <br> 📌 NEW YORK CITY <br> #Pizza #MadeInNewYorkPizza #NYC #NewYorkCity #Manhattan




  • Image 14: UPSIDE DOWN, ALL THE WAY 🔥🍕<br> Our Upside Down Square Pie flips the script — layering rich, slow-cooked tomato sauce on top of melty mozzarella, all on a thick, crispy, golden crust.<br> Every bite is saucy, cheesy, and ridiculously satisfying.<br> Square up and grab a slice — this one hits different 💥🍅




  • Image 15: Freshly baked, tossed in garlic butter, and sprinkled with parmesan — our garlic knots are the ultimate sidekick to any slice (or the main event, we’re not judging).<br> Soft, buttery, and impossible to eat just one 🔥<br> Grab a dozen. Thank us later.<br> #MadeInNewYork #NYCPizza #NYC #GarlicKnots




  • Image 16: EGGPLANT SLICE 🍆🍕<br> Our veggie friendly square made with charred eggplant, fresh mozz, juicy plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, and basil leaves (did we mention EVOO??)<br> Try a slice or order a pie at any MINY pizzeria across NYC 🔑<br> #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC




  • Image 17: SO MANY SLICES, SO LITTLE TIME 🍕🔥<br> From classic cheese and spicy pepperoni to eggplant parm, vodka sauce, and seasonal specials — we’ve got a slice (or a whole pie) for every kind of craving.<br> Fold it, stack it, savor it — there’s no wrong way to do it.<br> Pull up, pick your favorites, and let’s make it a pizza party 🍕💥<br> #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYCPizza




  • Image 18: WEEKENDS ARE MADE FOR MADE IN NY 🍕<br> Whether you’re stopping in for a slice or grabbing a pie to enjoy with your crew, we’ve got you covered. <br> Come taste our authentic, foldable, SAUCY, and ridiculously satisfying pizza 🔥🍕<br> #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC




  • Image 19: Get them while they’re HOT!🍕<br> Don’t let them cool down - all our slices are homemade right here in New York and are dripping with the best sauce in town.<br> #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC




Image 20: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


CHEESE SLICE, FTW 🍕 Our belief is pretty simple: Pizza is art & every aspect of it matters: Dough, sauce & cheese. Creating it is a ritual we’ve been practicing since our first shop opened up. You’ll taste the difference. ✔️ 📍 New York City 📌 Locations in West Village, Upper West Side, Midtown West & Broadway #PIZZA #NYC #NYCPIZZA #MADEINNEWYORK #MANHATTAN


2 days ago


Image 21: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


🍕 INTRODUCING THE NEW MARGHERITA. Stracciatella is king on this one, complimented by tomato, pecorino, basil & extra virgin olive oil. It’s just as crazy as it looks too. 😏 With FIVE locations across Manhattan, you don’t really have an excuse to not get this one in your hands. ♥️ 📍 Upper West Side, West Village, Midtown West, Broadway 📌 NEW YORK CITY #Pizza #MadeInNewYorkPizza #NYC #NewYorkCity #Manhattan


3 days ago


Image 22: UPSIDE DOWN, ALL THE WAY 🔥🍕<br>Our Upside Down Square Pie flips the script — layering rich, slow-cooked tomato sauce on top of melty mozzarella, all on a thick, crispy, golden crust.<br>Every bite is saucy, cheesy, and ridiculously satisfying.<br>Square up and grab a slice — this one hits different 💥🍅


Image 23: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


UPSIDE DOWN, ALL THE WAY 🔥🍕 Our Upside Down Square Pie flips the script — layering rich, slow-cooked tomato sauce on top of melty mozzarella, all on a thick, crispy, golden crust. Every bite is saucy, cheesy, and ridiculously satisfying. Square up and grab a slice — this one hits different 💥🍅


7 days ago


Image 24: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


Freshly baked, tossed in garlic butter, and sprinkled with parmesan — our garlic knots are the ultimate sidekick to any slice (or the main event, we’re not judging). Soft, buttery, and impossible to eat just one 🔥 Grab a dozen. Thank us later. #MadeInNewYork #NYCPizza #NYC #GarlicKnots


1 week ago


![Image 25: EGGPLANT SLICE 🍆🍕
Our veggie friendly square made with charred eggplant, fresh mozz, juicy plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, and basil leaves (did we mention EVOO??)
Try a slice or order a pie at any MINY pizzeria across NYC 🔑


MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC](https://scontent-dus1-1.cdninstagram.com/v/t51.75761-15/494049598_18270930712281854_3083718830736152631_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpg_e35_tt6&_nc_cat=103&ccb=7-5&_nc_sid=18de74&_nc_ohc=SU22ZkR7lr0Q7kNvwE4IbX1&_nc_oc=AdmQqof1KCOWDRVVI1Q-aogHK3pdJaGSktLKCsWjytYWkf75frUq_fmd4-KmhMPPeSg&_nc_zt=23&_nc_ht=scontent-dus1-1.cdninstagram.com&edm=ANo9K5cEAAAA&_nc_gid=AXiBtgZaP4EjrQN43mL9Wg&oh=00_AfKCvR7-NmA9zT-L6KVR-EE82UgFBQ6DpgWjcBueTtJfRQ&oe=68225368)


![Image 26: EGGPLANT SLICE 🍆🍕
Our veggie friendly square made with charred eggplant, fresh mozz, juicy plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, and basil leaves (did we mention EVOO??)
Try a slice or order a pie at any MINY pizzeria across NYC 🔑


MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC](https://scontent-dus1-1.cdninstagram.com/v/t51.75761-15/494304590_18270930724281854_3203413185567582108_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpg_e35_tt6&_nc_cat=101&ccb=7-5&_nc_sid=18de74&_nc_ohc=29Kxv3dpqxIQ7kNvwHnEOSd&_nc_oc=AdmgjbQg9Wv4v9I1aPgqm6TopNa89LPZfdFE3fX1WvXcfFWJVlYXwwhFTxFT-tFPc8A&_nc_zt=23&_nc_ht=scontent-dus1-1.cdninstagram.com&edm=ANo9K5cEAAAA&_nc_gid=AXiBtgZaP4EjrQN43mL9Wg&oh=00_AfIQDJhwbxGMsHsj0C4a9oflWbZlh3aNpJoU8IqFWFwW_g&oe=68225260)


Image 27: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


EGGPLANT SLICE 🍆🍕 Our veggie friendly square made with charred eggplant, fresh mozz, juicy plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, and basil leaves (did we mention EVOO??) Try a slice or order a pie at any MINY pizzeria across NYC 🔑 #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC


1 week ago


Image 28: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


SO MANY SLICES, SO LITTLE TIME 🍕🔥 From classic cheese and spicy pepperoni to eggplant parm, vodka sauce, and seasonal specials — we’ve got a slice (or a whole pie) for every kind of craving. Fold it, stack it, savor it — there’s no wrong way to do it. Pull up, pick your favorites, and let’s make it a pizza party 🍕💥 #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYCPizza


2 weeks ago


Image 29: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


WEEKENDS ARE MADE FOR MADE IN NY 🍕 Whether you’re stopping in for a slice or grabbing a pie to enjoy with your crew, we’ve got you covered. Come taste our authentic, foldable, SAUCY, and ridiculously satisfying pizza 🔥🍕 #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC


2 weeks ago


Image 30: @madeinnewyorkpizza


•


Get them while they’re HOT!🍕 Don’t let them cool down - all our slices are homemade right here in New York and are dripping with the best sauce in town. #MadeInNewYork #NewYorkPizza #NYC


2 weeks ago

Similar Businesses

Kesté Pizza e Vino

Pizza
4.6 (3,000)
Southbridge Towers
[email protected]
+1 212-243-1500